Autocar - First for car news and reviews

Advertisement

Top bloggers

Advertisement

Fri
Oct 24 2008

Insignia's telling tail lights

Hilton Holloway

This rather unusual-looking machine is the new Vauxhall Insignia estate, which made its public debut at the recent Paris show.
I had to take a step back when its huge clamshell tailgate automatically opened to reveal a pair of secondary rear light clusters hidden in the boot lining.

But this unusual layout prompted a piece of well buried piece of trivia to come to mind. There’s an obscure EU regulation that requires all of a car’s lights to be visible, even when all the doors and lids are open.

This law is the reason many estates have stacked tail lights, wrapped around the corners of the body and why the old Freelander and Discovery (which had side-hinged tailgates) had the brake and tail lights mounted in the rear bumper.

Further back in time, it's part of the reason front-hinged bonnets, such as those on the old 3-series and 5-series BMWs, were killed off.

At least one car maker has been caught out by the regulations. A few years ago I recommended the Toyota RAV4 to two buyers. They both went to the dealer and rejected the car for the same reason. The rear tailgate wouldn’t open fully.

This didn’t make any sense until I realized the Toyota was forced to fit a special EU-market check strap to the side-hinged rear door, preventing it from opening fully and obscuring one of the rear lights… Another thing struck me about the Insignia too. This estate was clearly conceived in the boom times. In these post-credit-crunch days, there’s no way a car would be passed for production with two pairs of rear light clusters.

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Hilton Holloway

Has two product design degrees and used to design mountain bikes. Realised that cars were a lot more interesting in 1990, and has been writing about them ever since.

Comments

DelgadosKnee October 24, 2008 4:01 PM

I actually think this is a good idea and surprised not more manufacturers have done it.  The inner lights only need to be cheapo jobs and it allows the entire boot to open in a much more accessible manner - important for an estate and much less likely to lead to scrathes and dinks as you unload that old pallet from the boot up at the tip on a sunday.

jimmy_j October 24, 2008 4:06 PM

The MINI Clubman has these lights...the rear doors open and leave the lights visible to traffic. Has saved my bacon once or twice!

TegTypeR October 24, 2008 6:18 PM

Here's a question.  Do they still operate when the tail gate is shut, or is there a switch?

It's that old fridge light question reincarnated.

Michael325 October 24, 2008 9:49 PM

Similar to the Porsche Carrera rear brake light(s). If you follw one that is braking from speed the light on the spoiler turns off and is replaced by the light on the back of the car when that becomes visible. So fascinating you could easily crash into the back of one.

dillonsamben October 26, 2008 4:57 PM

But what is the colour of the lining I can see in the photograph ?

Surely shouldn't estate cars be practical items that can carry all sorts of cargo without getting their internals all covered in shoite ?

If I were to load my 4 springer spaniels all covered in mud into that lardy tart of an interior, I know what it would soon look like !

Also, try opening some of these very large rear doors in a shopping carpark when tightly parked, the answer is so very often that you can't.

Just where are the brains in the car planning design studio ?

noluddite October 28, 2008 9:36 AM

That tailgate is so grossly over-engineered that it is truly hideous. The door on Apollo 13 was less complicated, and had a slightly more important role than keeping rain and draughts out. If it was 50mm thick, rather than 200, and the lights were fastened to the remaining pillars rather than the door, GM could have knocked several hundred quid off the price of the car. So where's the benefit for the buyer? Is having a tailgate the thickness of an Oak a USP? If GM believe this, I fear for the intelligence of the engineers and marketers.

nicfaz October 28, 2008 10:35 AM

The other thing about this is that those old BMW / Saab bonnets couldn't come unclipped and smack you on the windscreen whilst driving - I know a couple of people who've had lucky escapes when that's happened.  I think this legislation should only apply to the rear of the car...

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - Cover 07 Jan

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>