Autocar - First for car news and reviews

Advertisement

Top bloggers

Advertisement

Wed
Nov 19 2008

The MG Rover blame game rumbles on

James Ruppert

MG Rover just won’t go away, will it? There’s no chance of the corporate corpse being pushed into a quiet grave and left to rot in piece.

MG TF I’m talking about the Department of Trade and Industry’s inquiry into the downfall of our last indigenous volume car-maker. The current cost to Johnny Taxpayer for this is £13.5m – but it seems that, despite spending that, we’re not allowed to see it yet.

According to reports elsewhere, the so-called ‘Phoenix Four’ – erstwhile directors of the consortium which owned MG Rover – have intervened. John Towers, Nick Stephenson, John Edwards and Peter Beale have demanded that investigators conduct a new series of interviews before the report gets published. Apparently, they think that the Government should take more of the blame.

Of course, I can’t comment on blame or otherwise until I actually see a copy of the report. But even without that, I have to say the fantastic four should feel a bit sheepish about adding yet more expense to the whole thing, what with their huge salaries, £12.9m pension fund and various other windfalls they split between them as the company withered and died.

Many, certainly in the Birmingham area believe that the estimated £40m that the four amassed should be paid back, especially as the workers who lost their jobs as a direct result of the foursome’s management of MG Rover left Longbridge with just £2,800 each – and most of them are now earning substantially less than they were.

There, I’m glad I’ve got that off my chest.

 

Technorati Tags: ,,

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About James Ruppert

Used to sell BMWs, but he's no yuppie; has a '64 Mini Cooper in his garage and a '57 BSA Bantam in his house. Has bought and sold hundreds of used cars, and he isn't finished yet.

Comments

julianphillips November 19, 2008 1:26 PM

How can the government justify spending millions on investigating MG Rover when we still don't know the truth about Singer Automobile's acquisition by Rootes Group in 1956?!?

horseandcart November 19, 2008 1:44 PM

Well said Mr Ruppert, but it's looking like history's about to repeat itself about ten miles down the M42 motorway at Solihull, Land Rover(JLR) according to your breaking news headline.

Where in 2000 it was BMW having to hose cash on a rump of a business to get rid and avoid the political contamination of thousands of redundancies overnight now it's the turn of the UK taxpayer to bail out a bust JLR and ultimately a foreign tycoon, whose business bet went wrong.

Maybe John Towers et al are banking on the publication of the report being buried under an all engulfing crisis at JLR. They're probably saying to each other, give it a few more weeks, with some crafty blocking actions, and the last thing that'll be discussed will be £20m purloined by us nearly four years ago, when 10,000+ jobs are on the block up the road and Joe Soap is about to cough up hundreds of billions of pounds to an Indian billionaire. It's all relative James. Absolute business standards and having morals generally is so yesterday.

RobotBoogie November 19, 2008 3:08 PM

Am I the only person on site who thinks that the ultimate blame for the MGR fiasco lies with BMW and their managerial stragegies of "build what you like as long as it wouldn't look out of place on the set of Brideshead Revisited"? and "sell what you like as long as there is no chance at all that it will cannibalise sales from BMW". This gave MGR a target market of people aged 60-85 who lived in Kent and had pretty good pensions. And the 75 was aimed straight at them.

James Ruppert November 19, 2008 3:24 PM

Actually there is a book that I am not allowed to mention which makes that point. Do buy it for Christmas. BMW took what they could and scarpered and Rover probably was doomed from then because no one wanted to get involved, hardly surprising.

horseandcart November 19, 2008 3:24 PM

No RobotBoogie. The ultimate blame goes to Bernd Pischetsrieder(Issigonis's nephew) and anyone else on the BMW board c.1994 who thought it a good wheeze to buy Rover; only rivalled by Daimler-Benz's disastrous acquisition of Chrysler. Two basketcase, shell companies that suckered two gullible, flush with cash German companies, almost killing both of them in the process.

tortoise November 20, 2008 7:44 AM

I'm glad to see in these financially uncertain times that, we have nothing better to do/spend money on than raking up a dead dog. As patriotic as I am, backing a lame horse 'cos it's british, doesn't work. At the end of the day, despite what rover/MG had to offer the world, it wasn't good enough. Historically "our" government hasn't backed any home grown genious. (Think back to Frank Whittle...and more) British undustrial history is littered with the stigma of British Leyland and the Monday morning car. This was never ironed out of the british car industry. What do you all expect as an end result. Let it go people, and move on.

RobotBoogie November 20, 2008 5:55 PM

There's a lot of rewriting of history going on here. Rover Group was doing OK if unspectacularly selling remodelled Hondas and lashed up Land Rover products when BMW came along. It had even pulled the odd rabbit out of the hat like the MGF, largely made from bits of old Metro but a sales success for its whole life. Turned out that BMW had no idea how to manage a brand that wasn't BMW and had a management with a frankly bizarre view of the UK motor industry - anyone remember Pischetrieder's misty eyed plans for reviving Riley? Fact is that Rover Group developed some killer products for and with BMW - including the MINI and current Range Rover. Even the 75 was a very good car - it was just designed for a non-existent market. The problem was a. that BMW had no idea where the Rover brand should sit and b. resolutely refused to platform share, thus saddling Rover with massive development overheads which required huge sales increases to fund while c. refusing to let it apply the MG brand to any saloons in case they stole BMW sales. It was madness. BMW turned a marginally viable company that by now would probably by now be Honda's UK outpost into a complete basket case. It was a display of incompetent mismanagement beyond even the dreams of the British Leyland board.

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - Cover 07 Jan

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>