Autocar - First for car news and reviews

Advertisement

Top bloggers

Advertisement

Thu
Oct 30 2008

Time to bring bangers back?

James Ruppert

As the credit crunch starts to bite - and more and more people are realising that ploughing several tens of thousands of pounds into a shiny new car last year wasn't such a great idea - might I suggest a wholesale return to the old-fashioned phenomenon of the banger?

Vectra One of the cleverest - and dumbest - things I ever did was coining the phrase 'bangernomics'. Clever because it seemed to strike a chord with those seeking to trim motoring costs to the bare minimum, but deeply dumb because I've never been able to make any sizeable amount of cash for having come up with the concept.

The idea behind bangernomics is simple enough, it concerns the 'how to' of running a car on an almost non-existent budget. My dad once told me about its purest form, a guy he worked with who would rountinely spend no more than a fiver on a car and would never even open the bonnet.

I think he may possibly have added a little water sometimes, but it seems he averaged a good 18 months from each car before it expired by the roadside and he strode off to buy another.

These days we're a little bit more sophisticated, and we don't actually mind some small strategic spending on our motors - not least because of something called the MOT these days.

So we shouldn't resent paying for the odd tyre or brake parts - but use the 'walk away' defence when anything gets too pricey. So you should treat your ageing car to the occassional wiper blade, but cut-and-run when it chews up its automatic gearbox.

Of course, any bangernomist should be no stranger to the salvage yard, where the finer proponents of the art will take enormous pleasure in picking up the slightly grubby electrical widget for a tenner, the same one that the snide bloke in the service reception said was £699.99 plus VAT, plus fitting.

Despite the growing complexity of modern cars, a socket set, a Haynes manual and a willingness to give anything a try will still get you a surprising way. That said, a sympathetic garage that understands your predicament is an invaluable part of the keen bangerista's arsenal, too. We're talking about the sort of places that issue oil-smudged receipts rather than invoices on headed paper.

Then there's the ultimate banger dilemma: when something goes wrong, should I spend or scrap? The raw cost-benefit analysis of having to pay more than a car's nominal value to get it repaired has to be offset against factors like the fact you know the rest of the car is likely to last better than a bottom-budget replacement.

It could be as simple as asking whether you're fed up with it, or if you want a change. Bangernomics has never been a precise science - it's got everything to do with irrationality, prejudice, stubbornness and plain stupidity. And that's what makes it wonderful.

 

Technorati Tags: Bangernomics,used car,cash,MOT,scrap,second-hand car

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About James Ruppert

Used to sell BMWs, but he's no yuppie; has a '64 Mini Cooper in his garage and a '57 BSA Bantam in his house. Has bought and sold hundreds of used cars, and he isn't finished yet.

Comments

macaroni October 30, 2008 12:01 PM

I live by Bangernomics; my last 5 cars have cost me virtually nothing;

Pug 205 xs cost £150, sold for £350, several hundred over 5 years.

Pug 205 Mardi Gras cost £100, sold for £450, outlays £200 over 6 months.

Pug 306 xsi cost £100, sold for £800, outlays £500 over 6 months

Volvo 480 turbo cost £350, sold for £500, outlays £200, over 18 months.

Pug 205 gti cost £400, not sold yet, but worth about £750.

These figures don't include fuel/insurance/tax, but the actual cost and maintenance of the cars has been negligible.

W124 October 30, 2008 12:04 PM

Mr Ruppert Sir.

I commend you.  

W124.

Casanova October 30, 2008 12:17 PM

I love bangernomics.  My current Mondeo cost £290 and I am pleased to say it scored an unexpected pass in the speculative MOT test I gave it last month.  Apart from £40 for the MOT, and a litre of oil, its cost me nothing for 4 months and 5000 miles, and is undoubtedly worth more now (longer MOT) than when I bought it.  Bits fall off but it keeps going.  I shall miss it when I kill it.

theop October 30, 2008 1:16 PM

Macaroni clearly knows his Peugeots....

I admire you all.... and in fact i know somebody who makes a ( half )living off this.... not bangers per se, a click up from there...

5-7k cars, audi's, golfs tdi's etc....  buys them 3 at a time , shapes them up (while him and his wife use them for a few months) and then resells them...

Amazing what some polish and tlc does.. its all appearances...

he s making 15k a year on this I reckon....

TegTypeR October 30, 2008 1:25 PM

Fantastic!  I too practise bangernomics.  Please keep it quiet though because we'll all start to see the price of these cars rise soon if were not careful.

DelgadosKnee October 30, 2008 1:35 PM

Its true that the price of second hand cars in this country is very low, and I'm not sure why.  My brother lives in Australia and he tells me that second hand cars over there are very expensive compared to us.

I think you have to go Japanese for the best Bangernomics.  I had a £250 Nissan Sunny (the one that looked like a Triumph Accliam) that I swear would still be running today had the oil not all leaked out without me noticing and causing me to seize the engine up by driving with no oil.  My brother had a Mazda 323 estate that had done 250k mikes and he still used it off-road as a volunteer ranger (obviously not extreme conditions, but country tracks etc).

230SL October 30, 2008 2:09 PM

Passat TDI estates are a good start, even when parts add up to more than what you actually paid for the car it is still a lot less than the depreciation on a new one.

ColinS October 30, 2008 4:26 PM

I'm working my way down to pure (£500-£1,000) bangernomics. My Mondeo cost me £2K and a few parts and polish meant I sold it on for a profit. As was said earlier, it's all about appearances and buying smart means you can sell smart.

Said £2K bought a BMW which has done me over 20,000miles with little other than regular servicing. A daily commute of 120miles means the cheaper end gets a bit risky.

Cars over here are cheaper because of the oversupply of new cars driven by our fleet market and the desire of private individuals to keep up with their neighbours swanky motors. My colleagues abroad drive far less glamourous stuff seeing as it's funded from their own pockets. I still have a wry smile when a director level colleague gives me a lift in their 5yr old Clio or 10yr old Merc, can't see that happening here anytime soon.

People also still have this odd idea that old cars are unreliable - which hasn't really been the case since the mid 80's. It might help that I can wield a spanner if needed having grow up with less reliable stuff and can diagnose stuff for my trusty local garage to do at £40 per hour (vs £80-£100 for a main stealer) should I feel lazy or it to be too cold outside. Today's motorists are generally overly reliable on garages to sort problems out and therefore open to wallet abuse. Cheaper servicing and tyres (buy wheels on ebay, strip the tyres then resell wheels) are another saving over the newer stuff where not having a FDSH will hit your wallet.

Personally I'm looking forwards to all these cheap big cars (petrol for reliability and cheaper parts) coming along over the next few years.  If a £500 car lasts me 6 months it will be way cheaper than the £3K a year my nearly new stuff was costing me.

James Ruppert October 30, 2008 6:18 PM

So heartwarming to hear from you, especially after i was accused today of single handedly bringing about the collapse of the exotic car market, which isn't true, but it would be a wonderful achievement nontheless. Lets keep up the good work...J

michael knight October 30, 2008 8:37 PM

joined the crusade 6 months ago - £800 Pug 406 executive turbo petrol. commute 60 miles in it every day, radio doesn't work mut mechanically it trundles along just fine. all i need to complete the picture is a taxi sticker on the windscreen.

KPB October 31, 2008 10:10 AM

With a little shopping around you can also apply bangernomics to 'fun' cars. Recently I was in the market for something interesting to drive on the weekends and was shocked as to what you could pick up for less than a grand. Plenty of decent warm and hot hatches, the odd rough Fiat Coupe or Bimmer 325 etc...

I eventually got a slightly-shabby Jap domestic market Prelude 2.2 vtec (200bhp, 2ws with LSD), climate control, all electric and only 80k on the clock for £650. Not bad for something with bulletproof reliability and a sub-7 sec 0-60 time. With zero depreciation I can stomach the lower MPG than my daily driver diesel!

James Ruppert October 31, 2008 11:25 AM

That really is the way to do it KPB!

billybobthethird October 31, 2008 12:47 PM

I've applied a slightly different theory to this in the past, when I had more time on my hands...

I started off with a £150 Mk2 Golf GTI (sold for £500)and worked up to a Golf VR6 worth £2,500 with very minimal cash input from me.  Just a fair few weekends and trips to the local scrapyards.

This was back when Mk2 GTI's had reached rockbottom prices.  I stuck with VW's because I knew them well and they were easy to work on and get parts for.

vidfletch October 31, 2008 12:47 PM

1989 Volkswagen Jetta 1.8GL, owned for over 5 years. Wife drives it and I love it. Does 35 - 40mpg, comfortable and nearly as fast as a Gti. Spend £200 a year keeping it right. It cost £299 on Ebay but worth more in parts now! It's one of the family.

1990 Passat 2.0GT16V Estate too. Cost £430 and is better built, more reliable and has cheaper parts than any Merc of the time. It goes like stink! Did 42mpg on our holiday to France last year. Five of us, luggage and 80mph most of the way!

We also have 1995 VW Sharan 2.0CL. The VW bits are great but unfortunately a lot of the other bits are by Ford! It's shabby compared to the two above. Cost £900.

Unless I won the lottery there will never be new cars for us in the future.

Phinehas October 31, 2008 3:18 PM

I've lived by bangernomics for years and knew exactly where to track down specific models in the scrapyard. Big old cruisers have always been good value and I wore out most of the Renault 25s in Wales over a period of years. Now, I have a £3k car bought 5 years ago and converted to LPG. I've put close to 100k on it and only had to replace a few ancillary parts + routine servicing. Not true bangernomics, but a subset of it, I believe. I will keep this car -which takes me to Spain and back once or twice a year- until it dies completely but I won't have three grand to replace it. My other car is a very old and knackered ZX at 180 000 km on it today (Spanish, cost £150). How it passes its tests I will never know, but it just keeps going and is so basic that there is practically nothing to go wrong. It's also comfortable, unlike modern cars which go for Max Moseley seating and ride. My biggest fear is that the govt will make bangernomics illegal. I'll be off the road if that happens.

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - Cover 07 Jan

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>