Autocar - First for car news and reviews

Advertisement

Top bloggers

Advertisement

Wed
Sep 03 2008

Short on IQ

Hilton Holloway

[intro]In the Autocar car park, there's a tree that partially blocks a marked-out parking space. The space has, unsurprisingly, remained unused for months. Until, that is, Autocar began running a Smart long-termer. The three-meter long Smart is the only car that can squeeze into the space.

DSCF2741 The upshot is that the smallest car on the fleet is also the only one with a guaranteed parking slot.

Which is why I have to remain on the fence about Toyota's remarkable IQ. The fresh thinking and bespoke engineering that's gone into making a 3m-long car that can accommodate at least three adults (and that drives like a much bigger car) is hugely impressive.

But does it need to be that short? Perhaps there are thousands of drivers in the UK (the hints are that Toyota would like to sell 10,000 IQs per year) who look at the IQ and say, "Yup, just the job."

Perhaps you struggle to park on your daily commute and know just the spot you could squeeze an IQ into. Or perhaps it's the only second car that will fit onto the driveway next to the full-size family car. Perhaps.

_t3k0904But the IQ does not offer radically better fuel economy than a supermini, nor is it cheaper. It has less luggage space and less interior space -as brilliantly packaged as it is. Size matters, but I'm not sure that having such a tiny car is as big an advantage as might be claimed.

One story I heard about the gestation of the first A-class and Smart is that Mercedes's crystal-ball gazers became convinced that access to European city centres might be restricted based on a car's overall length.

In fact access to cities such as Munich is now restricted by an engine's pollution rating. In a couple of years anything dirtier than Euro IV will be banned.

In 2008, pollution is more important than size for European city drivers.The IQ will make more sense when its radical chassis is stretched to create the world's most space-efficient supermini.

 

Technorati Tags: ,,,

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Hilton Holloway

Has two product design degrees and used to design mountain bikes. Realised that cars were a lot more interesting in 1990, and has been writing about them ever since.

Comments

superstevie September 3, 2008 8:10 PM

I love our smart, got a 71 passion a month ago, and its been brilliant. Even taken it to scotland and back from essex and it coped very well. I'm sure the iQ will be a better car, but as majority of our journeys are with 2 or less people, the smart is better for us. I'd rather have useable boot space than cramped rear seats.

One thing that always makes me doubt the iQ is the fact the passenger is further forward than the driver. Surely this restricts some of the drivers view?

Plus, does anyone else think the iQ doesnt look right? the nose is all pointy, and the rear looks half finished.

Also, i know the smart doesn't have much of a rear impact zone, but the seats are heavily built and higher up to help in an accident. The rear passengers of an iQ don't have much crumble zone....

TUK September 4, 2008 8:48 AM

It's such a shame that the production of the Audi A2 ended. That car really was the template for a modern, hi-tech, space efficient supermini with ample space for four and their luggage, wrapped up in a premium small footprint package. It bettered the slightly shorter A-Class in its technology and efficiency.

Now imagine the A2 with an electric or hybrid powerplant for the 21st century ......... would you need an iQ then?

coolGav September 4, 2008 11:23 AM

I agree with TUK regarding the A2. It was ahead of its time, and I didn't buy one simply because there was non-manual version (fitting the VW DSG semi-auto would have made sense to me) for my wife. Supermini (of the time - they've all since grown) sized too...

I admire Toyota for developing the iQ, but I'm not sure it's right for the UK. Like superstevie, I'm unsure of its safety (primary and secondary). The market for small cars is there, but they do need to be able to carry some luggage, otherwise why have a city car that you can't take to the supermarket? As Hilton sums up, it's supermini packaging that needs more focus.

coolGav September 4, 2008 11:23 AM

I meant there was no non-manual A2

theoriginalshoe September 4, 2008 12:17 PM

Interesting discussion this.  I tend to think that this car might just fit the bill for enough people to make it a success.

Don't forget that the rear seats fold flat, meaning that you can have a big boot and let's face it: how often do you take three friends to the supermarket?!

giulivo September 5, 2008 10:46 AM

I agree, parking spaces in the UK are big. But expect to see plenty of IQ (or the future Fiat Topolino) in Rome where I came from, the city with the highest number of Smart Fortwo. The IQ seems to make much better sense, but at 3m it may already be too long for some. Already the revised ForTwo, at 2.7, makes some people miss the previous, 2.5 metre model, which you sometimes see parked across where others park in line.

giulivo September 16, 2008 10:12 PM

Hi Hilton, do I see a theme with your article on the ForTwo? There are people out there who have limited space to park in, at home and/or on the street. A modern day Punto is longer than the original Multipla or Tipo. A New Delta (should be a medium car) is as long as the original Croma (large family car). Compact MPVs like a Picasso or Zafira are longer than old time fullsize MPVs like the first Espace or 806. In all cases, with less interior space. When is this madness going to end? This clutters our cities and pedestrian safety is a poor excuse for extralong bonnets if the mammoth 159 only manages one star. The point is, cars should be taxed based on ACTUAL footprint. We already pay for our carbon footprint through fuel.

Oh, and the original A-Class (especially LWB) is the greatest car ever (I own one).

superstevie September 20, 2008 9:58 PM

[quote]Don't forget that the rear seats fold flat, meaning that you can have a big boot and let's face it: how often do you take three friends to the supermarket?![/quote]

Maybe not, but how much of a pain will it become to put those seats up and down every time you go shopping or go out with friends. And lets face it, lots of girls (and boys) go shopping with their friends. Where are they going to put all their bags?

And I've still to see an arguement about rear end shunt safety and being in the rear seats...

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - Cover 07 Jan

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>