Autocar - First for car news and reviews

Advertisement

Top bloggers

Advertisement

Fri
Jun 20 2008

Tata gets off to a good start

Andrew Frankel

At a time when a good news story in the car industry is becoming an increasingly scarce commodity, how heartening and reassuring it is to hear that Tata’s first action since buying Jaguar and Land Rover is to inject £700 million into the brands and create 600 new jobs in the UK.

LR Shop True, the money had already been earmarked by Ford before the sell-off and, yes, much of it will go towards dropping emissions levels so the marques don’t get clobbered by forthcoming legislation (had the companies stayed part of Ford their high CO2 emissions could have been offset against the comparatively low average emissions of its former parent’s products), but money is money and if it helps these two become leaner and more competitive then that is good work that needs doing now.

Even so, what is needed most is new product. This must be particularly galling for the marques concerned given that, between them, they have churned out a completely new XK, XJ, XF, Discovery, Range Rover Sport and Freelander all in the last five years, but such is the position in which they find themselves today. Jaguar needs to kill the X-type and build an F-type while Land-Rover has to decimate the kerbweights of the next Rangies and Discos while fast tracking the LRX into production.

LRX It’s a hard call and I suspect that in the transitional period (and presuming the F-type and LRX get the green light) things will be tough.

Even so, both brands have four priceless assets: their names, an owner clearly prepared to put its money where its mouth is, lightweight manufacturing technology (an aluminium XJ limo weighs less than certain versions of the steel X-type), and staff with the talent and dedication to make it happen.

If I was one of them right now, I’d be quietly very excited about the next five years.

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Andrew Frankel

Talents are limited to "driving cars and writing English." In 19th century France he would, therefore, have been stuffed; as it is, Andrew's the perfect Autocar road test writer.

Comments

loather June 22, 2008 8:50 AM

Get real sunshine. Of the two(Jag and LR) Land Rover is dominant in sales and revenues yet has just returned the worst staisfaction and reliability ratings in Which(UK) survey and JD Power(Germany) surveys.

Land Rover's three core products, RR/RR Sport/Discovery are grossly overweight. They will need to lose at least 300Kg to be current competitive, never mind next product cycle competitive with X5/M class/Q7 etc.. Defender is suffering from bad image through Army use in Iraq and Afghanistan and is likely to lose orders to heavier, armoured mine-resistant vehicles and the Freelander relies heavily on Volvo/Ford design and technology. Not a pretty picture in total. What's happening to GM and Ford in the States currently with their trucks/big SUVs presages what's about to happen to Land Rover.

Once the current product cycles and engine contracts run out I predict Land Rover and Jaguar will wither and be sold off, what's left, to Alfa Romeo(Jag) maybe or majority of remaining production moved overseas, Land Rover to India, all within 3-4 years max.

Foilball June 22, 2008 11:49 AM

A suitably apocolyptic and cynical view loather, and one I find hard to argue against. Though whether Alfa Romeo (ultimately Fiat) would want or need to take on the Jag Brand is another matter.

I also agree with your views on the current LR line up, which is beginning to look distintly silly given current conditions. However I live in Middle East and the RR Sports is almost a common a sight on the roads here as are Land Cruisers so sales here a particularly strong. Unsurprsing as petrol costs next to nothing - £12 to fill up my Jeep anyone? However there is evidence that LR is wising up to the need to keep weight down and can be seen by the some of the recent concepts (LRX for example) which seem to be close to production reality.

As for Jag, well the efforts they are going to inject freshness into their model lineup give me hope for their future and I am seriously thinking about  an XKR for my next car. I do not fit Jag's traditional customer profile - I am under 30 - and the fact that the brand appeals to my age range means hopefully they are moving in the right direction.

I for one hope both survive.

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - Cover 07 Jan

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>